3 Comments

User's avatar
Maybe: Tyler's avatar

Lovely photos as always!

I still haven't been to Minneapolis but hopefully I will someday soon -- I'm very curious about it because of how hyped it is among Winnipeggers. However, looking at maps of it, it's insane how dense its freeway network is, even compared to other American cities that are larger.

Winnipeg's transportation system is one of my biggest gripes with the city, even coming from Edmonton, which isn't the best place for transportation planning, but feels like a breeze by comparison. What I find annoying is that there's just no space in discourse for pedestrians or transit. It's all about cars, and maybe cycling if you're lucky. And yet, Winnipeg is annoying to get around via either because the city hasn't properly developed the infrastructure. There's no freeways or grid of arterials and the bike lane network is a sorry patchwork.

It boggles my mind that a city that was built so much around rail transit has no vision for LRT or streetcars, just BRT. And BRT is fine and all, but not the way Winnipeg does it, based on the Blue Line. I'm a huge proponent of public transit, probably more than any other mode of transport, and it pains me to say that I avoid Winnipeg Transit as much as possible despite not owning a car because of how terrible it is. And there's no activism around it. Nor for pedestrians. Even the covid-era "open streets" thing that so many cities did for pedestrians and cyclists was technically only for cyclists in Winnipeg, and had huge backlash from entitled drivers in Wellington Crescent.

But then you walk around or go to a show and clearly see the urgent activist streak in Winnipeg. But it doesn't translate into anything for better urban policy. No push for limiting sprawl, free transit, bikesharing, eliminating parking minimums, banning drive thrus, or any of the newfangled ideas that have been floated around and even implemented in cities like Edmonton and Minneapolis. And it's so crazy-making because Winnipeg has such incredible potential.

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts